Sports. Honestly. Since 2011

A photo of prolific WWE Elimination Chamber competitor Randy Orton.
February 20, 2026 By  Pro Wrestling, WWE, WWE Universe

Cold Steel, Calculated Chaos: Randy Orton’s WWE Elimination Chamber Performances Revisited

  1. New Year’s Revolution 2005 (San Juan, Puerto Rico) 

New Year’s Revolution 2005 hosted just the third Elimination Chamber match, and it did not disappoint. It featured an incredible lineup competing for the vacant World Heavyweight title, as Randy Orton, Triple H, Batista, Edge, Chris Jericho, and Chris Benoit all battled in the exciting contest. 

Many argue that this match featured more compelling storylines than any other Elimination Chamber bout in history. The most notable elements were Shawn Michaels as the special guest referee and Orton’s intense rivalry with Triple H following being kicked out of Evolution. 

Orton entered the match fifth, focusing much of his energy on Triple H. But the “X-Factor” of this star-studded showcase wasn’t just their rivalry, but rather the brewing tension between Batista and Triple H. In a shocking turn, Orton eliminated Batista by delivering a low blow, which is legal in the Chamber, followed by an RKO. 

Triple H’s decision not to help Batista avoid being eliminated caused further friction within Evolution. As Orton and Triple H battled as the final two, Ric Flair provided a distraction that allowed a recovered Batista to blindside Orton with a clothesline. Triple H immediately followed up with a Pedigree to claim the vacant World Heavyweight Championship. 

This performance showcased Orton’s transition from student to a legitimate main-event hero, driven by his intense feud with Evolution. His elimination of Batista and the dramatic final moments of the match with Triple H proved he could hold the crowd’s attention as well as he could execute a perfect RKO. The pattern of Orton reaching the final two only to fall just short started here. 

About Nicholas Paul

Nicholas is a graduate of Sheridan College's Journalism Program and has been an avid WWE fan since childhood. Nicholas offers analysis of WWE’s narratives and booking strategy, focusing on storytelling and character development. He'll also be offering his opinions on the creative direction and strategic decisions shaping the WWE landscape.