Why Moving Schneider is the Canucks Best Move

By
Updated: March 10, 2013
Cory Schneider

As the trade deadline approaches, so does the ever present debate on which teams might pull the trigger on a big trade.  Although the roar of the rumors sending Roberto Luongo to the Leafs, or was it the Panthers, or was it the Flyers, have mostly subsided, now would be the best time for the Canucks to pull the trigger on a trade for either one of their starting netminders.

So, who do they trade?

Everyone recognizes Cory Schneider to be a worthy NHL starter.  He has come out and said that he wished to have a starting role on an NHL team.  Luongo has essentially asked for a trade, partly to allow his friend Schneider to have his own net, and partly because he feels that he needs a change.  However, as much as Luongo wants to leave for greener pastures (I’m looking at you Florida Panthers), and as excited as Leafs Nation got in the off-season at even the hint of possibility that Luongo could find a home there, it is unlikely that the Canucks will be able to move Luongo and his contract.  Let’s face it, the Luongo contract could be the gross domestic product of a small developing nation over the same period of time.

That said, Schneider could be on the move.  There are a couple of reasons for this.  Firstly, his cap hit is significantly less.  He is a top flight starter in a conference that seems to breed starting goaltenders like rabbits.  Also, out east there are more than one suitor that would be willing to give up the appropriate amount of players/prospects for Schneider, but might not be able to afford Luongo’s asking price.

One appropriate suitor for the Canucks might be the New Jersey Devils.  The Devils, although they have three goaltending prospects in their system, neither  Scott Wedgewood, Maxime Clermont, nor Keith Kinkaid are ready for the big show.  The Devils have shown, after losing 6 of their last 7 with aging backup Johan Hedberg in net, while ageless wonder Marty Brodeur is sidelined with a back injury.  Before the losing skid, the Devils were at the top of the Eastern Conference heap. Now they are 2 points away from being out of a playoff spot.

Another team that could use the help in goal are the Toronto Maple Leafs.  Unfortunately, it seems that Leafs Nation may not be interested in Schneider as they’ve deluded themselves into believing Ben Scrivens and James Reimer are both legitimate NHL starters and adequate enough to backstop the Leafs to their first post season berth in almost a decade.  Hopefully, reality sets in and the Leafs decide to bring someone in an actual starter, but, at least for the moment, goaltending has seemed to slip off Dave Nonis’ radar.

Carolina, as much as they wish to ride out Cam Ward’s injury with what they’ve got, is in a precarious position.  Washington has begun their surge behind exceptional goaltending by youngster Braden Holtby, are only 6 points behind the Canes, and seem to be making a real run to get back into the hunt for a post season berth.  If the Canes drop out of the division lead, either to Winnipeg or Washington, they could go from division leader to out of the playoff picture in the matter of a few games. The Canes may come around, and make a push for Schneider.

Lastly, the Philadelphia Flyers are a possible suitor for a Schneider trade.  Ilya Bryzgalov has “amnesty buy-out” written across his forehead, and has been mostly unimpressive since signing on with the Flyers.  Of course, nothing says broken record than the city of Philadelphia turning perfectly good NHL goaltenders into blithering, spastic idiots that can’t stop a beach ball.  That said, the Flyers could be looking to add someone more stability if they find themselves in the grey area between in the playoffs and on the outside looking in.

Mostly, the teams mentioned above would not be willing to make a push for Luongo.  However, if Schneider were to become available for a trade, the Canucks might find themselves with a boon of suitors, and may be able to pick the greatest return on their investment on Cory Schneider.

Thanks for reading, as always feel free to leave comments below and follow me on twitter @BigMick99. Give the rest of the hockey department a follow while you’re at it – @lastwordBKerr@IswearGaa and @LastWordOnNHL, and follow the site @lastwordonsport.

Interested in writing for LastWordOnSports?  Visit our Join our Team page and be heard!

photo credit: bridgetds via photopin cc

One Comment

  1. ryan

    March 11, 2013 at 12:29 pm

    Tampa Bay – It’s going to be a long wait for their 2012 1st rounder. Goaltending has scuppered what should have been a contending season. Yzerman is going to have to re-evaluate his hatred for investing dollars in goalies.
    Columbus – Bob is coming on but with a new GM in town and the affection JD has for Schneider, I could see him going there easily.
    Winnipeg – Pavalec has been hit and miss and Winnipeg has seen Schneider before
    Florida – I think they are a better fit for Lou, but still a possibility until Markstrom takes over than het.
    New York Islanders – Nothing but air behind Nabakov
    Philadelphia (off-season)- Are they really that crazy?
    Phoenix (off-season) – Smith may not return
    Minnesota (off-season) – Harding has MS, Hackett is young and Backstrom is a UFA
    Pittsburgh – MAF has a few years yet to run on a big contract, but he is way too inconsistent in net. I could see Pittsburgh kicking the tires on another gaolie.
    New Jersey – Brodeur has one more year and NJ lack the high picks and prospects needed to get a deal done. What do they offer? Larsson is not available and I am not sure a Merril Josefson package gets it done.
    Toronto is a possibility I suppose.

    Forget Carolina – not going to happen. They have a long term deal with Ward. Ellis is OK for now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>