The Chicago Cubs have announced they will not pick up left-handed pitcher Drew Smyly’s player option for the 2025 season. Smyly, who signed a two-year contract with the Cubs prior to the 2023 season, was expected to be a steady part of the rotation and bullpen. However, with the team opting to decline his option, it’s clear they may be looking to pivot in their approach to the pitching staff in the upcoming offseason. Here’s a closer look at what this move signifies for Smyly and the Cubs.
Cubs Decline Left-Hander’s Player Option
Cubs decline Drew Smyly $10M option
— Jon Heyman (@JonHeyman) November 2, 2024
Smyly’s Season In Review
Smyly’s 2023 and 2024 seasons were, unfortunately, inconsistent. His fluctuating ERA over his handful of relief appearances placed him in a challenging spot as the Cubs fought for a playoff spot late in both seasons. Despite his experience and ability to eat up innings, Smyly struggled with control and keeping the ball in the park. His walk and home run rates saw increases compared to prior seasons, making him a liability in key games.
These struggles likely influenced the Cubs’ decision to decline his player option, as the organization sought more dependable arms for a rotation that showed promise and inconsistency throughout the year.
Cubs’ Pitching Plans Moving Forward
Declining Smyly’s option opens up both a roster spot and financial flexibility as the Cubs eye the offseason market. With Shota Imanaga and Justin Steele at the top of the rotation, the team could use the additional payroll to bring in a solid third or fourth starter with a more consistent track record. Additionally, the Cubs have several promising young arms in the pipeline—like Cade Horton and Ben Brown—who may see more opportunities in the rotation next season.
This decision reflects a trend that’s been emerging in recent years: a move toward younger, cost-controlled pitchers who can provide stability. Smyly’s departure signals that the Cubs are ready to invest in a new direction, either by exploring free agency or by calling upon their talented minor-league prospects.
Possible Landing Spots For Smyly
For Smyly, the market may still hold opportunities despite a difficult season. A veteran left-hander with starting experience remains a valuable asset for teams looking for depth. Smyly’s appeal could be strongest for clubs aiming to bolster their rotation with a low-risk, high-reward option.
Teams that struggled with rotation depth in 2024, or those in need of a lefty with postseason experience, may view Smyly as an affordable option. Clubs such as the St. Louis Cardinals, seeking to revamp their pitching staff, or perhaps even the Los Angeles Angels, often searching for veteran arms, could be potential fits for Smyly.
A Pivotal Offseason For The Cubs
By declining Smyly’s option, the Cubs have set a tone for a pivotal offseason that will shape their roster heading into 2025. This move marks just one of what could be several changes, as the front office aims to position the team for a deeper postseason run. Cubs fans can expect to see the organization actively pursuing new arms and potentially some familiar faces as they seek to make the most of this critical offseason.
Smyly’s time in Chicago may have ended, but his contributions will be remembered. As the Cubs chart a new course for their pitching staff, they remain committed to building a competitive team for future seasons.
Main Photo Credits: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
