When ranking the best first basemen in Milwaukee Brewers’ franchise history dating back to 1970, it’s interesting to look at the long, storied tradition of success at the high-profile position. With a combination of power and finesse, each player on the shortlist has left a distinct mark. Prince Fielder’s recent induction into the Wisconsin Athletic Hall of Fame on April 20, 2024, poses an intriguing question about who ultimately is the best.
Ranking The Best Brewers First Basemen
1. Cecil Cooper (1977-1987)
Cooper remains firmly entrenched as the top first baseman in Brewers history. The five-time All-star drove in the memorable game-winning run versus the California Angels in Game 5 of the American League Championship Series, sending Milwaukee to the World Series in 1982. “I remember what kind of team we had, the type of guys we had, and the togetherness,” said Cooper (in an interview with Baseball- Reference.com’s David Zingler in 2003). “We played as a team, had fun as a team, and had great camaraderie. People genuinely liked each other, to me that’s what it’s all about.
“I got the game-winning hit and was very fortunate to get the opportunity to get that hit. I failed in a couple of opportunities before that in that game and I got another chance – that’s what you ask for. That’s probably the one, single moment (that stands out in my career).”
The Brewers legend finished his 17-year career with 2,192 hits, a .298 batting average, 241 home runs and 1,125 RBI. He won three Silver Slugger Awards and two Gold Glove Awards.
October 10, 1982: Cecil Cooper drives in the run that would eventually be the game winner to send the Brewers to the World Series pic.twitter.com/lZU0SVp8p5
— The Brew Crew Scoop (@BrewCrewScoop) February 24, 2024
2. Prince Fielder (2005-2011)
The six-time All-star played seven seasons with the Brewers, leading the team back to prominence in the mid-2000s. The memorable stretch was highlighted with postseason appearances in 2008 and 20011. Known for his explosive, power-hitting throughout his memorable time in Milwaukee, he generated 230 home runs. He set a single-season franchise record with 50 homers in 2007. Fielder was the picture of durability, missing just 13 games, including only one throughout his final three seasons.
Fielder finished his 12-year MLB career with 1,645 hits, a .283 batting average, 319 homers and 1,028 RBI. He won the Silver Slugger Award three times and was named All-Star Game Most Valuable Player in 2011.
9/22/09 Prince Fielder clubs 41st home run of the year. #Brewers pic.twitter.com/sVK7Cr8b8X
— Historical Baseball Stats (@HistoricalBaseb) May 5, 2024
3. George Scott (1972-1976)
The three-time All-Star played five seasons with the Brewers. 1975 Scott led the American League with 36 home runs and 109 RBI. He finished his 14-year MLB career with 1,992 hits, a .268 batting average, 271 home runs, and 1,051 RBI. He also earned the prestigious Gold Glove Award eight times.
George Scott bashed the ball during his 5 yrs w @Brewers (1972-76). He led the AL with 36 HRs & 109 RBIs in 1975 & twice led the AL in total bases. Big Boomer also won 8 GG as a 1B in his 14-yr #MLB career. Check out his @sabr bio https://t.co/dvprBCMlaT pic.twitter.com/OdlSwpQBr1
— SABR BioProject (@SABRbioproject) December 10, 2020
Honorable Mentions
Throughout the years many other players have made positive, lasting contributions at the first-base position for the Brewers. Richie Sexson, Greg Brock, Eric Thames, John Jaha, Lyle Overbay and Jesus Aguilar also made noteworthy impacts during their limited time.
In looking at the impressive list, it’s clear to see the difference between strong players with potential and enduring legends of the game.
Main Photo Credits: Rick Wood / USA TODAY NETWORK
