2. Ryan Tannehill
Having Ryan Tannehill second on this list shows just how desperate the Colts are. Indianapolis is very familiar with what Tannehill brings to the table, having faced him twice a year from 2019 to 2023. While he’s no superstar, he proved he can operate efficiently when surrounded by an elite run game and at least one above-average receiver. Jonathan Taylor is in the same tier as Derrick Henry, and while the Colts don’t have anyone who can match A.J. Brown’s talent, they have a deep group of wide receivers.
The biggest problem here is that Tannehill hasn’t played football since 2023. While Tannehill hasn’t officially filed paperwork to retire, Tannehill said he had no interest in returning to the league. However, the quarterback could make an exception for the Colts. While Tannehill clearly has no interest in being a backup, he might entertain the possibility of returning as the unquestioned starter on a team fighting for a spot in the playoffs.
