The 2025 NFL season began with the Buffalo Bills winning their first four games, sparking high hopes as favorites. But back-to-back night losses to the New England Patriots and Atlanta Falcons changed everything: Bills Mafia, once seen as the NFL’s most loyal fans, now turned into harsh critics.
Coming out of the Bills’ bye week, criticism from the Bills Mafia has intensified, now focusing on head coach Sean McDermott for not addressing the obvious issues plaguing Buffalo’s offense and defense. Offensive coordinator Joe Brady is likewise under fire for being “too cute” on offense, despite past successes with innovation. The scrutiny has recently shifted to GM Brandon Beane, as fans dissect his last few draft classes and question his reluctance to sign big-time playmakers during the off-season, instead choosing to invest in current roster players.
Ultimately, neither extreme, the initial belief that Buffalo was unbeatable nor the recent notion that everything is wrong, fully captures the team’s reality. While some issues persist, such as Joe Brady admitting poor play calls on jet sweeps that led to fumbles, and injuries across key positions like wide receiver, linebacker, and defensive line, the path forward remains clear. The Bills’ leadership can now focus on targeted improvements to get back on track by Week 8.
Reestablish Offensive Identity and Consistency
The 2025 Buffalo Bills offense is in a paradoxical situation. Buffalo has long built its identity on being a physical team that plays well in any conditions, which is why the Bills are building their new stadium as an open-air stadium. But if a team has a “tough” weather-proof offense that involves a strong running game and the ability to use play-action plays to make opposing defenses pay for overcommitting to stopping the run game, it can be a formidable opponent.
A common thread in the Bills’ two losses is that they are not approaching their game plan with this identity in mind. Instead, it seems Joe Brady is trying to build an intricate, gimmicky offense to position himself for a future NFL head coaching role. This has resulted in turnovers and a lack of continuity in the game plan, making it easier for defenses to make stops against Buffalo when the Bills commit unforced errors. This bye week is a good time for the Bills to get back to the basics and return to having a fundamentally sound offense going forward.
Make Defensive Adjustments to Improve Run Defense
During an in-game interview on Monday Night Football, Sean McDermott attributed their poor run defense to the inability of their defensive front players to control their gaps. That is a big reason for the Bills’ failure to stop their opponents’ rushing attack, but that problem has also been magnified by multiple injuries to their defensive line and linebackers. Therefore, the Bills’ poor run defense is a dynamic problem that does not have a straightforward schematic solution.
Buffalo’s top priority is to shore up health at the interior defensive line and inside linebacker, as trading for reinforcements is unlikely due to salary cap commitments. Therefore, the team must rely on current roster solutions, namely the return of Michael Hoecht and Larry Ogunjubi from league suspension after missing the first six games for PED violations.
Bills Must Go All-In and Trade for a Deep-Threat
The hottest topic in the NFL this time of year is which teams should trade for before the NFL trade deadline on November 4. Many people are advising Buffalo to trade for cornerbacks, safeties, and defensive linemen. However, what those advisors are not accounting for is the significant investment the Bills already made in this position group during the draft and free agency. Investing more capital into position groups that already have answers is not a good strategy for building a championship team.
In contrast, the Bills’ offense lacks a legitimate deep-threat wide receiver to open up the field and create explosive plays. Most receivers available would not be upgrades over the current group. The exception is New Orleans Saints wide receiver Chris Olave, who is rumored to be available for draft picks. If Buffalo wants to maximize their championship chances this season, Olave is the clear trade target.
Follow me on X: @AaronSauter7
Main Image: Gregory Fisher-Imagn Images
