The managers at Last Word on Sports hosted a 2025 dynasty rookie mock draft with analysts from Footballguys, JWB, and multiple other fantasy sites. It was four rounds, superflex, one point tight end premium and had some shocking picks. Here are the results with analysis for some of the biggest surprises and best values.
For full audio, check out the recording of the rookie mock draft here.
2025 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft Results – Superflex TEP
First Round Results
1.01 Ashton Jeanty, RB Boise State
Ashton Jeanty All-22 Film Study
1.02 Cam Ward, QB Miami
This might have been a little early for a quarterback, but in a superflex league it’s not the worst idea.
1.03 Omarion Hampton, RB UNC
1.04 Tetairoa McMillan, WR Arizona
1.05 Jaxson Dart, QB Ole Miss
If the first round buzz around Dart is real, okay. But there are still four of the top five running backs available, two exciting tight ends and a couple wide receivers to consider first.
1.06 TreVeyon Henderson, RB Ohio State
1.07 Quinshon Judkins, RB Ohio State
1.08 Emeka Egbuka, WR Ohio State
1.09 Luther Burden, WR Mizzou
1.10 Travis Hunter, WR/CB Colorado
If Hunter plays WR full time, this is an absolute value. If he only mixes in on 30% of snaps, it’s a nightmare for a first.
1.11 Kaleb Johnson, RB Iowa
The last of the top five running backs off the board, Johnson didn’t blow up the Combine so this could be about his range in April.
1.12 Tyler Warren, TE Penn State
All-22 Film Study on Tyler Warren
Second Round Results
2.01 Shedeur Sanders, QB Colorado
2.02 Matthew Golden, WR Texas
2.03 Bhayshul Tuten, RB Virginia Tech
One of the biggest Combine risers from the weekend, Tuten could be an explosive day two back available in the early second of rookie drafts.
2.04 Colston Loveland, TE Michigan
The only issue with the Tuten pick was that Loveland was still available.
2.05 R.J. Harvey, RB UCF
2.06 Tre Harris, WR Ole Miss
Harris’ analytical profile from 2024 is one of the best ever, not just in the class. Durability, transferable skills from the Ole Miss system and projected role are all still lingering questions.
2.07 Mason Taylor, TE LSU
2.08 Jayden Higgins, WR Iowa State
2.09 Harold Fannin Jr., TE Bowling Green
2.10 Jalen Milroe, QB Alabama
Milroe is going to be one of those quarterbacks that if he plays, he’s in your fantasy lineups. But how much will he play?
2.11 Cam Skattebo, RB Arizona State
The forgotten RB after the Combine, Skattebo skipped the speed tests but is still a very solid back.
2.12 Dylan Sampson, RB Tennessee
Third Round Results
3.01 Devin Neal, RB Kansas
3.02 Elijah Arroyo, TE Miami
3.03 Jaylin Noel, WR Iowa State
Noel could be a day two NFL pick with blazing speed, he’s either a great value here or fool’s gold depending on his landing spot.
3.04 Ollie Gordon, RB Oklahoma State
3.05 Kyle McCord, QB Syracuse
3.06 Jalen Royals, WR Utah State
3.07 Elic Ayomanor, WR Stanford
Ayomanor ranges from top five to outside the top ten on some folks’ wide receiver prospect lists for 2025.
3.08 Brashard Smith, RB SMU
3.09 Xavier Restrepo, WR Miami
3.10 Jack Bech, WR TCU
3.11 D.J. Giddens, RB Kansas State
3.12 Damien Martinez, RB Miami
One of the early RB sleepers for 2025, Martinez tested just well enough to slide under the radar but still provide optimism.
Fourth Round Results
4.01 Gunnar Helm, TE Texas
Helm was crushed from the Combine until it came out he injured his ankle. If he tests better at his pro day, he’s back into top five tight end consideration.
4.02 Raheim Sanders, RB South Carolina
4.03 Isaiah Bond, WR Texas
4.04 Terrance Ferguson, TE Oregon
4.05 Jarquez Hunter, RB Auburn
4.06 Dillon Gabriel, QB Oregon
Gabriel was a Combine faller at the QB position, but he might stick around the league as a serviceable backup.
4.07 Savion Williams, WR TCU
4.08 Isaac TeSlaa, WR Arkansas
4.09 Tory Horton, WR Colorado State
4.10 Tai Felton, WR Maryland
4.11 Nick Nash, WR San Diego State
4.12 Woody Marks, RB USC
The best advice to give in this 2025 dynasty rookie mock draft is to take swings on running back late. Old WR prospects and backup quarterbacks don’t win dynasty championships, but hitting on a fourth round rookie running back who can either be the handcuff or lead back for an offense will. This class is deep at running back, so don’t be afraid to load up on darts there.
Main Photo Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
