Sports. Honestly. Since 2011

Justin Fields Vs. Caleb Williams: Who Will Be QB1 In Chicago?

The Chicago Bears face a crucial decision that could reshape their future – keeping Justin Fields or drafting Caleb Williams. This has been the main conversation surrounding the Bears, and General Manager Ryan Poles has a pivotal decision to make this offseason.

Dilemma For The Chicago Bears: Justin Fields Or Caleb Williams?

The Case To Draft USC Quarterback Caleb Williams

With the Carolina Panthers plunging toward the number one draft pick (that the Bears currently own), the expectation is for the Bears to reset the clock and take the top quarterback with the Panthers’ draft pick.

USC quarterback Caleb Williams appears to be the consensus No. 1 overall pick. Williams is an exceptional talent, winning the Heisman trophy in 2022 and having that rare trait of making something out of nothing. His improvisational style catches the eyes of many, even getting compared to Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes. Williams is a generational talent; barring a dramatic comeback by Fields in the final few weeks of the season, it seems unlikely that the Bears will pass up the opportunity to choose Williams in the draft.

Sticking With Justin Fields

Let’s be honest. Will the Bears be better off with Williams? No matter who the quarterback is in Chicago, they seem to not perform at the highest standard. Subsequently, it looks like the Bears finally have a quarterback capable of producing astonishing plays that few quarterbacks can make in the league.

Fields is by no means a perfect quarterback, but it is also not fair to put all the blame on Fields. The combination of poor coaching, lack of talent on offense, and not putting Fields into positions to be successful needs to be considered when evaluating Fields. Not just that, but Fields has all the intangibles you want in a franchise quarterback. He’s athletically gifted and has a natural ability to be a leader. It’s hard to give up on such a talented quarterback after only two full years as a starter in the NFL.

A Third Superstar In The Mix?

Honestly, it’s nice to be an observer rather than the one making the decision. Poles has to decide whether to risk his job on Fields or draft Williams. Ultimately, no matter what Poles decides, it should excite Bears fans. The next question is this: Is there another prospect worth taking if the Bears decide to pass on Williams? In all honesty, no. Ideally, the Bears find a trade partner to move out of the first pick if they decide on sticking with Fields and pass on drafting Williams, but if they can’t, there might be one prospect worth drafting number one overall.

Wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. (MHJ) from Ohio State is the consensus WR1 in the upcoming draft, and he’s the top-rated prospect regardless of position. MHJ is a generational prospect, just like Williams. If the Bears genuinely want to commit to Fields being the starting quarterback, the best way to help him succeed is to draft a generational offensive weapon that can elevate the offense. Selecting a wide receiver with the first pick overall would be audacious, but MHJ is one guy who certainly deserves it. He and D.J. Moore would be a phenomenal wide receiver duo for the Bears.

The Ideal Scenario For The Chicago Bears

The case in point is that whatever happens with the Bears this offseason will happen for a reason. Williams is a superstar, and Fields deserves more time as the Bears starting quarterback. It’s hard to make everyone happy, and the decision about what to do at the quarterback position in Chicago will be criticized and overanalyzed by many.

While there’s no perfect scenario for the Bears, many fans are eager about one specific option: moving back one spot to the second overall pick, selecting MHJ, and continuing to accumulate draft capital. Considering that the majority of Bears fans are hoping to keep Fields, this approach aligns with their desire to acquire a generational talent in MHJ.

Ultimately, whether it’s Williams or Fields starting at quarterback for the Bears next season, the fans and the organization should fully support and root for him to succeed. The future of the Bears’ quarterback position remains uncertain, but it is expected to be a defining moment for the team.

Main Image: Jeffrey Becker-USA TODAY Sports


More Posts

Send Us A Message