Ravi Ashwin v Nathan Lyon – The Conundrum
Ashwin vs Lyon. Could the duel decide the test series?
India will play Australia in a four test series down under, starting from the 17th of December. They won the last series 2-1 in 2018/19 but the return of Steve Smith, David Warner and the emergence of Marnus Labuschagne could potentially put Australia on top. Oh, and Virat Kohli may miss three tests due to the birth of his first child.
” Cameron Green is going to be a superstar” says Ashton Agar
Ravi Ashwin and Nathan Lyon, both are great spinners and respective match winners for their team. But the question which arises who has performed better in their respective Test careers which has lasted for more than a decade as of now.
Also, Read – Picking India’s All-Time Test XI
The best way would be to check their statistics since their debut, so we’ll analyse that. Another important point to be noted is that both their performances have improved since 2015, and also it’s necessary to know how the bowler has performed in the past few years, so we’ll also compare performances since 2015, simultaneously.
Ashwin: Wickets-365, avg-25, Bowling SR-54 (132 innings) Lyon: Wickets-390, avg-32, Bowling SR-63 (184 innings)
Ashwin: Wickets-251, avg-23, SR-50 (90 innings) Lyon: Wickets-256, avg-30, SR-61 (110 innings)
Ashwin has proven better in this parameter.
Home and Away performances
Let’s compare how Ashwin and Lyon have performed at home and overseas conditions
Ashwin: Wickets-254 avg- 23 SR-49 (83 innings) Lyon: Wickets-191 avg- 32 SR-64 (92 innings)
Ashwin: Wickets-159 avg- 22 SR-48 (53 innings) Lyon: Wickets-117, avg- 32 SR-67 (54 innings)
Ashwin: Wickets-111 avg-31 SR-63 (49 innings) Lyon: Wickets-199 avg-31 SR-62 (92 innings)
Ashwin: Wickets-92 avg- 26 SR-54 (37 innings) Lyon : Wickets-139 avg- 28 SR-56 (56 innings)
Ashwin edges past Lyon here too.
“Watching Babar Azam is a treat for the eyes” says Ravi Ashwin
Performances in Asia and outside Asia
Generally, it’s seen that the Asian wickets are more spin-friendly, whereas pitches outside Asia favour the faster bowlers. So, here we’ll take a look at how have they fared in Asia compared to outside Asia.
Ashwin: Wickets-297, avg- 23, SR-48 (97 innings) Lyon: Wickets-95, avg-31, SR-59 (37 innings)
Ashwin: wickets-202, avg- 22, SR-47 (67 innings) Lyon: wickets-69, avg-25, SR-52 (21 innings)
Ashwin: Wickets-68, avg- 38, SR-78 (35 innings) Lyon: Wickets-295, avg-32 , SR-64 (147 innings)
Ashwin: wickets-49, avg- 30, SR-65 (23 innings) Lyon: wickets-187, avg-32, SR-65 (89 innings)
In Asia, Ashwin is better whereas outside Asia it’s Lyon who has outperformed him if we take account of their performances throughout the career. But when we see performances since 2015, Ashwin has improved by leaps and bounds.
But since, Ashwin has outperformed Lyon in 3 out of 4 parameters, so this one goes to Ashwin.
Performances against Top Tier Teams
The Top Tier Teams are surely the SENA and India in Tests, and let’s analyse their respective performances against these teams.
Ashwin (against SENA): wickets-234 avg-27 SR-59 (85 innings) Lyon (against SENI): wickets-266 avg-31 SR-63 (126 innings)
Ashwin (against SENA): wickets-154 avg-24 SR-54 (53 innings) Lyon (against SENI): wickets-163 avg-31 SR-63 (73 innings)
Ashwin wins here too.
The Match Winner
Now one more question remains unanswered that, “Agreed Ashwin has better stats than Lyon, but does he win matches for Team India?
Surely he does.
Man of the Series awards for Ashwin: 7 awards in 28 series Man of the Series awards for Lyon: 1 in 31 series.
Man of the Matches for Ashwin: 7 in 71 matches, i.e. 10.1 matches per award. Man of the Matches for Lyon: 4 in 96 matches, i.e. 24 matches per award
How has ICC rated them?
Let’s check how many times have both of them appeared in ICC Test Teams of the year, and what their rankings have been over the years in the ‘ICC Bowlers Rankings’ in Tests.
ICC Test Team appearances
Ashwin was selected in the ICC Test Team of the Year in 2013, 2015, 2016, 2017 i.e. 4 times. Whereas Lyon was selected in the ICC Test Team of the Year in 2018 and 2019, i.e. 2 times.
So, that is yet another parameter, and Ashwin has outperformed Nathan Lyon.
Let’s check the ICC Bowler Rankings for both of them, who’s ranked above? Ashwin or Lyon?
Rankings in the starting of 2020: Ashwin: 9 Lyon: 19
2019 (starting): Ashwin. 8 & Lyon: 14
2018 (starting): Ashwin. 4 & Lyon: 9
2017 (starting): Ashwin. 1 & Lyon: 18
2016 (starting): Ashwin. 1 & Lyon: 14
2015 (starting): Ashwin. 13 & Lyon: 16
2014 (starting): Ashwin. 7 & Lyon: 16
2013 (starting): Ashwin. 20. & Lyon: 25
2012 (starting): Ashwin. 37. & Lyon: 49
They both have debuted in the later half of 2011, so I didn’t include the rankings of 2011 starting, as both hadn’t debuted at that time.
Surely it’s Ashwin. It’s Ashwin who has been the top spinner for so many years, was also the No.1 bowler in 2016–17, and has also remained in the top 5 for a huge amount of years.
Main Image Credit:
Embed from Getty Images