Is Phaneuf the Most Over-rated NHL Player?

                                Sports Illustrated polled 160 NHL players, asking each who is the league’s most over-rated player.  Most players picked Toronto Maple Leaf Captain Dion Phaneuf.

Who do you think is the NHL’s most over-rated player?  Have your say here.

…and that is the last word.

2 Comments

1. 

   Anonymous

   January 12, 2012 at 9:35 am

   Yeah Carey Price, he sucks man!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He did very well in junior, leading Team Canada to the World Junior Hockey Championship, and the Hamilton Bulldogs to the Calder Cup. But he hasn’t done anything in the NHL, besides win one lousy playoff round. He was in net when the Habs got swept by the Bruins in 2009. When the habs went on their 2010 run to the Eastern Conference Final, Halak took over for Price and backstopped them.

   Which leads me to my original point!!!!! Price sucks and can’t get the job done under the pressure!!!!!!

   Reply
2. 

   Mike

   January 12, 2012 at 6:27 pm

   Hmmm…. very interesting conversation starting. I’m not sure who is THE most overrated, but a few come to mind:

   Lupul – not that I think he’s bad, I just don’t think he can/will keep up this pace.

   Reply